Stranger on the Third Floor

RKO (1940) Dir. Boris Ingster
64 min. / B&W / 1.37:1 / DTS-HD 2.0 Master Audio / SDH
Warner Archive Blu-ray $24.98
Available from Movie Zyng

Phenomenally odd and weird little movie, an unsettling little B picture that creeps out at you like a fat spider from under the couch.

Margaret Tallichet and John McGuire are a (rather colorless) young couple struggling to make enough money to get married; she's a secretary, he's a cub reporter. Well, his ship comes in when he witnesses a murder and gets the exclusive story as his own star witness, sending young Elisha Cook, Jr. to the Death House. Trouble is, there's some nagging doubts in Maggie's mind that John saw what he thinks he saw, and when a neighbor of his is brutally murdered in the same way, is it possible that Cook is innocent and a strange, odd little man spotted lurking about in the shadows is a serial killer?

None of this may sound like much, and in fact, a lot of what I just described occurs in the opening couple of minutes! This movie's barely an hour long; there's no room for a lot of set-up, folks. Peter Lorre gets massive star billing, but is hardly in this thing, although he certainly makes the most of his part, particularly playing against the rather dull leads. Best of all is a lengthy dream sequence that just has to be seen to be believed, weird as all get-out. This is considered by many to be the first true film noir; maybe, I wouldn’t swear to that or argue against it, but it's a good example of the genre and a terrific little film gem. The guy who plays the bank examiner in It's a Wonderful Life is McGuire's next-door neighbor, and you'll never want to see a movie character end up as one of the victims as much as you'll be hoping THIS guy goes!

Miss Tallichet, while showing no chemistry with her leading man, was astoundingly beautiful; turns out she was carving out a nice career for herself when she married director William Wyler, who preferred her to stay home and have babies. I wonder how far her film career would've gone. Director Ingster was a screenwriter who stepped in to direct 3 or 4 pictures; besides this one, he also gave us the superior noir crime drama Southside 1-1000.

The new Blu-ray from Warner Archive is a big, big improvement over the previous DVD release of this film and includes two Warner Bros. character-less but gag-filled cartoons, Ceiling Hero and Wacky Wildlife, but the big treat is an audio-only three-pack of a radio show starring Mr. Lorre called Mystery on the Air. We rarely have time to listen to these things but we’re very glad we did; Lorre is terrific and the scripts are great fun and suitably spooky. Give ‘em a listen.

A lot of people live in Brooklyn. Why couldn’t I? Then I wouldn’t be mixed up in all this!”